The row and now investigation over the dramatic price increases during the sale of Oasis tickets has raised the profile of dynamic pricing and I imagine that consumer response to it (whether in theory or in practice) will come down to an assessment of the situation against a number of concepts, including – but probably not limited to – aspects such as the magnitude of the change, the reasons why the price has changed, the speed at which the price changed, the intrinsic, underlying ‘value’ of the product offered, the similarity of the product, the ability to substitute the product, the ‘perishability’ of the product, the emotional attachment one has to it and the extent to which the news spreads.
There’s likely no set of fixed ‘rules’, but how these all interplay with one another is what is likely to influence opinion.
If we take the case of Oasis tickets, what we had was an established intrinsic price for a ticket (even allowing for different categories, within those categories the product is basically identical) that increased very dramatically and very quickly for no reason other than a high level of demand.
On top of that, it was a product to which consumers had a very strong emotional pull – heightening the disappointment at missing out – and for which there was no immediate substitute available (not even a nearby Blur concert). A media frenzy around the sudden, unexpected “Pax Gallaga” meant the ticket sale was always going to be headline news, consumed and commented-on by millions, the nature of the fixed on-sale date and queueing mechanism meant consumers were effectively shoe-horned into a buying window and the dynamics of the fraternal relationship mean that this is opportunity unlikely to recur again and again. (Frankly, buying for anything other than the opening night is something of a gamble).
What I think really irritated consumers was the immediacy and magnitude of the price correction, the “limited time only” circumstance and the immediate comparability of many thousands of tickets that were ostensibly identical and had been anchored at a particular price. It wasn’t so much “dynamic pricing” as an overall concept that drove annoyance, it was “surge pricing”, which comes across – perhaps rightly, too – as opportunistic and exploitative. Throw emotion into the mix and everything just gets that bit more intense, while there is a special place in hell reserved for those who hoover up these tickets to then attempt to sell them on at a huge mark-up – often while people are still queuing to buy directly. Having experienced the disappointment of missing out on Paul McCartney tickets myself recently, I was amazed at how many Tweeters’ plans had “suddenly changed”, making them unable to attend a concert I was still 18,000 places away from being able to buy.
If you consider hotel rooms, each ‘enquiry’ is different and it has become accepted that there is, as a result, no underlying price for a night in a hotel. The prices don’t tend to fluctuate either dramatically or immediately, and the justifications for higher prices, although significantly linked to demand, are not exclusively explained by it – very few hotel rooms could be considered completely identical* to each other – perhaps dozens at most on only the largest of corridors – so there is always a justification for a different price somewhere. Much as brand owners may like to believe otherwise, very few consumers are so emotionally drawn to a hotel brand that its unavailability will cause distress, and very few brands are so unique that there aren’t half a dozen similar alternatives in immediate proximity. What’s also true is that prices can go down as well as up, something that never got the chance to be tested for Oasis tickets. For that reason, the game feels less rigged – sometimes you’re the statue, but sometimes you’re the pigeon!
Although the hotel sector may find itself, to a certain extent, protected from the worst of the backlash by the differentiation inherent in its offering, the relative stability of its pricing and the relative indifference towards its offering, that shield is not impenetrable. Despite all the above, at the positional excesses of bad behaviour there is still reputational harm to be won by those who try hard enough. Outrageous increases in price for no other reason than ‘because we can’ are likely to make people feel exploited, while cancelling lower-rated rooms to rebook at a higher rate – whatever term of the small print is invoked – just feels unfair.
Although, interestingly, when we looked into the reverse concept – that of guests cancelling a room because they’d found one cheaper – only a very, very small percentage of consumers would refrain on the grounds of fairness to the hotel. The barriers to “book-cancel-rebook” were far more practical in nature; to the point where if someone or something makes it quick, easy and risk-free, there’d be a very, very large slice of the market prepared to do it should the opportunity arise.
‘Big, evil corporations’ just have to put on their big-corporation pants and suck that sort of thing up, I’m afraid.”
*identical size, location, layout, view, configuration, etc, at an identical time

